Sugar Me Sweet? or Not?

alcohol sugars diabetes monk fruit stevia sugar sugar substitute Oct 20, 2024

Understanding Sugars and Their Impact on Blood Sugar Levels

Sugars come in many forms, and their effect on the body varies based on their type, source, and rate of absorption. Here’s a breakdown of common types of sugar:

Common Sugars:

Type of Sugar	Source	Calories per teaspoon	Carbohydrates per teaspoon	Sugar Release Time into Bloodstream	Notes
Table Sugar (Sucrose)	Derived from sugar cane or beets	16 cal	4g	Quick release	Common in processed foods
Fructose	Found in fruits	16 cal	4g	Slower release than glucose	More easily stored as fat
Lactose	Found in milk and dairy	16 cal	4g	Moderate release	Requires lactase enzyme for digestion
Molasses	Byproduct of sugar refinement	19 cal	5g	Quick release	Higher in vitamins and minerals than refined sugar
Honey	Produced by bees	21 cal	5.7g	Quick release	Has trace minerals but similar impact to sugar
Maple Syrup	Extracted from maple trees	17 cal	4g	Moderate release	Contains antioxidants

Table Sugar (Sucrose): This is the most common form of sugar, a combination of glucose and fructose, and is rapidly absorbed, leading to a spike in blood sugar levels.
Fructose: Naturally found in fruits, it has a slower release into the bloodstream than glucose but can contribute to fat storage if consumed in excess.
Lactose: The sugar in dairy, lactose requires the enzyme lactase for digestion. Some people may be lactose intolerant.
Molasses: A byproduct of the sugar refining process, molasses contains more vitamins and minerals like iron and calcium than table sugar but still has a high caloric content.
Honey and Maple Syrup: These natural sweeteners offer more nutrients compared to refined sugar, but they still impact blood sugar similarly.

Sugar Substitutes:

Sweetener	Source	Safe Daily Amount	Baking Usage	Possible Side Effects	Safe for Pregnancy & Kids?
Stevia	Plant-based	4 mg/kg body weight	Heat stable	Bloating, nausea in high doses	Generally safe
Sorbitol (Sugar Alcohol)	Fruits & plants	No defined upper limit	Heat stable	Gas, bloating, diarrhea	Safe in moderation, but avoid excess for children
Monk Fruit	Fruit-based	No limit specified	Heat stable	No known major side effects	Safe for all
Sucralose (Splenda)	Synthetic sweetener	5 mg/kg body weight	Heat stable but can break down at high temps	Gastro issues in excess	Safe for pregnancy, children in moderation

Stevia: A natural sweetener derived from the Stevia plant, with no calories and a negligible impact on blood sugar levels. Stevia is heat stable, making it suitable for baking, but can sometimes leave a bitter aftertaste.
Sorbitol: A sugar alcohol found in fruits and vegetables, used in sugar-free products. While it doesn’t spike blood sugar levels, it can cause gastrointestinal discomfort if consumed in large quantities.
Monk Fruit: Derived from a fruit, monk fruit sweetener has zero calories and does not impact blood sugar. It’s safe for children and pregnant women and works well in baking.
Sucralose: Commonly known as Splenda, this is a synthetic sweetener that can be used in baking, but there is debate about its safety at high temperatures as it may break down and form potentially harmful compounds.

Baking with Sugar Substitutes:

When baking with sugar substitutes, it’s essential to adjust the recipe since many substitutes are sweeter than sugar. For example:

Stevia: 1 teaspoon of stevia is equivalent to about 1 cup of sugar, but it may require modifications to the liquid content in recipes.
Sorbitol and Monk Fruit: These can be used in a 1:1 ratio to sugar, making them easy to substitute in recipes.
Sucralose (Splenda): Splenda can be used cup-for-cup like sugar in most recipes, but consider the possible breakdown at high heat for long cooking times.

Note: Blends of sugar substitutes can be tricky, as some blends may contain fillers like maltodextrin, which can still spike blood sugar. It’s important to read labels carefully.

Quality vs. Quantity

Reducing the amount of sugar you use in recipes is often a healthier option than relying on substitutes. For example, using applesauce in place of some sugar in baking not only cuts down on calories but also adds fiber and nutrients. Other natural baking swaps include using mashed bananas, pureed dates, or pumpkin puree to lower sugar content.

Baking Swaps:

Applesauce: Replace half of the sugar in a recipe with unsweetened applesauce.
Bananas: Use mashed ripe bananas to replace sugar; adds natural sweetness and moisture.
Dates: Puree dates for a caramel-like sweetness that pairs well in muffins and brownies.
Pumpkin Puree: Adds moisture and natural sweetness, along with a dose of vitamins.

Muffin Recipe Comparisons:

Muffin with Sugar and Applesauce:

Ingredients: 1/2 cup applesauce, 1/4 cup sugar, 1 cup whole wheat flour, 1 egg, 1/4 cup vegetable oil
Calories: ~140 per muffin
Sugar: 9 grams per muffin

Very Berry Muffin with Stevia:

Ingredients: 1/2 cup applesauce, 1 tsp stevia, 1 cup whole wheat flour, 1 egg, 1/4 cup vegetable oil
Calories: ~120 per muffin
Sugar: 3 grams per muffin

As you can see, using stevia significantly reduces the sugar content while keeping the caloric content lower.

Conclusion:

While there are many sugar substitutes available, the best approach is often to reduce overall sugar intake and focus on nutrient-dense swaps like applesauce or bananas in baking. Substitutes like stevia and monk fruit can be useful but always check for blends and side effects. Quality over quantity is key, and a balanced approach to sweetness can help you meet your health goals.

Interested in ways to Rethink Diets and Nourish to Flourish Click here for my newest course and connect with others in our community

https://www.kariecassell.com/nourish-membership